Document Type : Original Research Paper
Authors
Faculty of Mining Engineering, Mineral Processing Research Institute, Kim Chaek University of Technology, Pyongyang, Democratic People’s Republic of Korea
10.22044/jme.2025.15581.2986
Abstract
Shaking table and flotation are often used in scheelite (CaWO4) beneficiation, and usually they are applied in sequence. In this paper, analysis of mineral movement have been investigated in shaking table in which pulp was conditioned with xanthate as a collector and fed, heavy scheelite was concentrated, while heavy pyrite removed directly on the deck by the action of collector. Artificially mixed mineral with 1% scheelite and 2% pyrite was used in CFD simulations and experiments. Through CFD simulations, it was found that pyrite particles, which were hydrophobic by collector, were attached to the water-air interface and subjected to upward buoyancy, which increased the density difference between scheelite and pyrite particles and enabled the separation of both minerals in the shaking table. The experiment results showed that the concentrate grade in conventional table concentration was 23.5% WO3, the separation efficiency was 77.89%, while the concentrate grade of scheelite in the table concentration of xanthate presence was 65.0% WO3 and the separation efficiency was 80.88%. The combination of flotation in table with collector addition not only eliminated the flotation to remove pyrite after table but also resulted in a lower rate of scheelite loss.
Keywords
Main Subjects
[1]. Xu Wang., Wen Qing Qin., Fen Jiao., Liu Yang Dong., Jian Gen Guo., Jian Zhang., Cong-Ren Yang. (2022). Review of tungsten resource reserves, tungsten concentrate production and tungsten beneficiation technology in China. The Nonferrous Metals Society of China. 32, 2318−2338
[2]. B.V. Das., S.K. Nagesh., C.H.R.V.S., Sreenivas, T., Kundu, T., Angadi, S.I. (2023). A treatise on occurrence, beneficiation and plant practices of tungsten-bearing ores.Powder Technology, Vol 429
[3]. Xiaosheng Yang. (2018). Beneficiation studies of tungsten ores–a review. Minerals Engineering, 125, 111–119
[4]. Wang, Y. (2016). Beneficiation process optimization for a tungsten ore. China Tungsten Industry, 253(03), 37–40
[5]. (2023). Flotation chemistry of scheelite and its practice: A comprehensive review. Minerals Engineering, Vol 204, 2023
[6]. Wang Cong., Ren Shuai., Sun Wei., Wu Si-hui.,Tao Li-ming., Duan Yao., Wang Jian-jun., Gao Zhi-yong. (2021). Selective flotation of scheelite from calcite using a novel self-assembled collector [J]. Minerals Engineering, 171: 107120
[7]. Yao Wei., Li Mao-lin., Zhang Ming., Cui Rui., Shi Jia., Ning Jiang-feng. (2020). Decoupling the effects of solid and liquid phases in a Pb-water glass mixture on the selective flotation separation of scheelite from calcite [J]. Minerals Engineering, 154: 106423
[8]. Dong Liu-yang, Jiao Fen, Qin Wen-qing, Wei Qian. (2021). New insights into the depressive mechanism of citric acid in the selective flotation of scheelite from fluorite [J]. Minerals Engineering, 171: 107117
[9]. Foucaud Y., Filippov L., Filippova I., Badawi M. (2020). The challenge of tungsten skarn processing by froth flotation: A review [J]. Frontiers in Chemistry, 8: 230
[10]. Zuo, Z., Gao, Y. (2016). Research advances of the processing technologies for the wolframite - scheelite mixed ore in China.China Tungsten Industry. 31,253(03),41-45 (+54)
[11]. Huang et al. (2016). Recovery Technology of Poly-metallic Sulfide Ore in China's Tungsten Mines. China Tungsten Industry, 31,251(01),58-62+73
[12]. Sheng, X., et al. (2015). Experimental study on recovering copper in the mixed sulfide ore of a tungsten mine. China Tungsten Industry. 249 (05), 49–53
[13]. Wu, Y., Zhou, Y. (2015). Flotation technology experiments of a high sulphur Cu-Zn-WO3 poly-metallic ore. China Tungsten Industry. 245(01), 44–48
[14]. Dai, X. (2016). Experimental Study of a Low-Grade Tungsten Molybdenum Ore. China Tungsten Industry, 31, 252(02) 26–3
[15]. Barry A. Wills. (2016). Mineral Processing Technology. Mc Gill University, Montreal, Canada 233~235
[16]. Sarbast Ahmad Hamid., Pura Alfonso., Josep Oliva., Hernan Anticoi., Eduard Guasch., Carlos Homann Sampaio., Maite Garcia-Vallès., Teresa Escobet. (2019). Modeling the Liberation of Comminuted Scheelite Using Mineralogical Properties. Minerals, 9, 536
[17]. Anticoi, H., Guasch, E., Hamid, S.A., Oliva, J., Alfonso, P., Garcia-Valles, M., Bascompta, M., Sanmiquel, L., Escobet, T., Argelaguet, R. (2018). Breakage Function for HPGR: Mineral and Mechanical Characterization of Tantalum and Tungsten Ores. Minerals, 8, 170
[18]. M.T. Carvalho, E., Agante, F., Durao.(2007). Recovery of PET from packaging plastics mixtures by wet shaking table. Waste Management, 27, 1747–1754
[19]. Sivamoham., Forssberg., (1985). Principles of tabling. International Journal of Mineral Processing,15, 281—295
[20]. R.J. Manser., R. W.Barley., B.A.Wills.(1991). The Shaking Table Concentrator-the influence of operating conditions and table parameters on mineral separation-the development of a mathematical model for normal operating conditions. Minerals Engineering, Vol. 4, No.3/4, 369-381
[21]. Tucker, K., A.Lewis., P. Wood. (1991). Computer optimization of a shaking table. Minerals Engineering,Vol.4,No.3/4, 355-367
[22]. R. Razali.,T.J.Veasey. (1990). Statistical modeling of a shaking table separator. Minerals Engineering, Vol. 3, No.3/4, 287-294
[23]. S. Torno., J. Torano., M.Gent., M.Menendez., (2011). A study of hydrocyclone classification of coal fines by CFD modeling and laboratory tests. Minerals & Metallurgical Processing, May; 28, 2.
[24]. Gu Jun Wan et al. (2008). Solids concentration simulation of different size particles in a cyclone separator. Powder Technology. 183, (94–104)
[25]. Viduka, S., Feng, Y., Hapgood, K., Schwarz, P. (2013). CFD–DEM investigation of particle separations using a sinusoidal jigging profile. Adv. Powder Technol, 24, 473–481
[26]. Yunkai Xia, Felicia F. Peng, Eric Wolfe, 2007.CFD simulation of fine coal segregation and stratification in jigs. J. Miner.Process, 82, 164–176
[27]. M. Rudman., D.A. Paterson., K. Simic. (2013). Efficiency of raking in gravity thickeners. Advanced Powder Technology, 24, 473–48
[28]. M.R. Fatahi., A. Farzanegan., (2018). An analysis of multiphase flow and solids separation inside Knelson Concentrator based on four-way coupling of CFD and DEM simulation method. Minerals Engineering, 126, 130–144
[29]. Ananda Subramani Kannan., Klas Jareteg., Niels Christian Krieger Lassen., Jens Michael Carstensen., Michael Adsetts Edberg Hansen.,Flemming Dam,SrdjanSasic. (2017). Design and performance optimization of gravity tables using a combined CFD-DEM framework. Powder Technology, 318 423-440
[30]. Ozcan Yildirim Gulsoy., Ergin Gulcan. (2019). A new method for gravity separation: Vibrating table gravity concentrating. Separation and Purification Technology, Vol 211, 18, March. 124-134
[31]. P. Pavanello., P. Carrubba., N. Moraci. (2018). The determination of interface friction by means of vibrating table tests. Geo textiles and Geo membranes, Vol.46.No. 6. 830-835
[32]. Koh, P.T.L., Schwarz, M.P., Zhu, Y., Bourke, P., Peaker, R., Franzidis, J. (2003). Development of CFD models of mineral flotation cells. In Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Computational Fluid Dynamics in the Minerals and Process Industries, Melbourne, Australia, pp. 171–175
[33]. Guichao Wang., Anh V., Nguyen., Subhasish Mitra., J.B. Joshi., Graeme J. Jameson., Geoffrey M. Evans. (2016). A review of the mechanisms and models of bubble-particle detachment in froth flotation. Separation and Purification Technology,170, 155–172
[34]. Koh, P.T.L., M.P. Schwarz. (2006). CFD modeling of bubble–particle attachments in flotation cells. Minerals Engineering, 19, 619–626
[35]. Schelud K, A., Toshev, B.V., Bojadjiev, D.T. (1976). Attachment of particles to a liquid surface (capillary theory of flotation). Journal of the Chemical Society, Faraday Transactions 1: Physical Chemistry in Condensed Phase,. 72, 2815–2828
[36]. Guichao Wang., Linhan Ge., Subhasish Mitra., Geoffrey M. Evans., J.B. Joshic., Songying Chen. (2018). A review of CFD modelling studies on the flotation process. Minerals Engineering, 127,153~177
[37]. Anh V. Nguyen. (2003). New method and equations for determining attachment tenacity and particle size limit in flotation. Int. J. Miner.Process, 68 167–182
[38]. Gardner, L. R., Woods, R. (1971). An electrochemical investigation of contact angle and floatation in the presence of alkyl xanthates, II. galena and pyrite surfaces. Aust.1. Chemistry, 30, 981-991
[39]. Jan Drzymala. (1994). Characterization of materials by Hallimond tube flotation. Part 2: maximum size of floating particles and contact angle. Int. J. Miner.Proces, 42, 153-167
[40]. Schulz, N.F. (1970). Separation efficiency. Trans. SME/AIME, 247 (Mar.), 81-87
)